Why a 1099 rate has to be higher
A W-2 employee's cost to the employer is more than the hourly rate. The employer pays its half of FICA — 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare, 7.65% in all — and usually health insurance, a retirement match and paid days off. A 1099 contractor gets none of that and pays both halves of Social Security and Medicare themselves as self-employment tax. A contractor also only earns for the hours they can bill: time spent on admin, finding work and waiting between contracts is unpaid.
How this calculator works it out
It adds up the annual value of the W-2 job: pay (rate × hours per week × 52, since paid days off are paid), the employer's FICA share, the retirement match and the benefits you enter. It adds any business costs you will carry as a contractor. Then it divides the total by the hours you can bill: 52 weeks minus your paid days off (at five days a week), times hours per week, times your billable share. With the defaults — a $50 rate, 40 hours, 20 days off, $6,000 of benefits, a 3% match and 85% billable — the equivalent is about $74.19 an hour, 1.48 times the W-2 rate.
Self-employment tax, more precisely
Self-employment tax is 15.3% (12.4% Social Security plus 2.9% Medicare), charged on 92.35% of net self-employment earnings, and half of it is deductible for income tax. Those adjustments make the true extra cost slightly less than the flat 7.65% this calculator adds, so the result errs a little high. Social Security tax also stops at an annual wage base, so above it the employer's share — and your self-employment tax — is smaller. Income tax, state taxes, unemployment insurance, bonuses and equity are not modelled.
This is a US-only estimate for comparing offers, not tax advice. A tax professional can apply it to your situation.